Quote:
Dan has a point to a point. When all cars had drum brakes, all cars sort of had stopping distances in the same ball park. Today the average modern car will stop in a 20% plus shorter distance than the cars of the sixties, and in a straight line.
Just remember to keep back several extra car lengths over the normal distance in a modern car, and hope the guy in front doesn’t clamp on the binders real hard because you will eat all that extra space real fast. Also don’t expect the next hard stop to be as short as the first if the brakes are still hot, stopping distances will increase drastically.
That actually helps make my point, you're selling the idea that drum brakes have inferior stopping power and cannot stop in a straight line. A vehicle that cannot stop in a straight line has faults in the brake system regardless if it is drum or disc. The improved stopping power of today's cars can be contributed to power assist and anti-lock being standard equipment.
If you could improve your stopping power by switching to discs the DOT would have mandated disc brakes on our semis long ago. But it not only didn't happen, disc brakes were tried sometime back in the '90s have been mostly phased out since they offered no improvement. The new trucks we buy today have pretty much the same brake system that was revised/mandated in 1975, air chamber S cam with drum brakes. Of course they've added anti-lock as well now.
I'm not trying to sell anyone on drum brakes
over discs, just that there is nothing wrong with drums in good working order. The only real issues with drums are:
1) They are a PITB to work on.
2) Not many
know how to work on them.
3) Like RT pointed out, they do not like water, good driving practices will keep you out of trouble here.
4) They do not cool off very quickly, so again good driving practices come into play. However they're not going to overheat by making a high speed panic stop or two, it takes riding the brakes and/or hauling a heavy load to cause serious brake fade.
I have two Ford F250s, one is a '69 with 4 way power drum. The other is an '85 F250 with power disc/drums. The '85 is a diesel, the rear drums are huge, the front discs are sporting dual piston calipers.
Both trucks stop almost equally well, with or without a load. (Usually a travel trailer or loaded equipment trailer. And over Buckhorn summit no less.) If anything the '69 stops better, but I contribute that to it being a slightly lighter truck than the '85.
[/i]