Quote:
I'd jump on that Straight Line deal and be happy it can be rebuilt...
Hey Mr. W.,
Was elated to receive the very PROMPT reply from Ralph at Straight Line Steering, Inc. It held out hope for Lorrie's
Gemmer Y4D-335 RHD Manual Steering Gear Box where OTHERS held out only doom and gloom.
Quote:
No farting around re-engineering, welding, sourcing unseen parts that may or may not cobble up satisfactorily.
There IS something to be said for not having to figure out how to pull a VERY iffy project back from the brink. And all would be well if the solution that made that possible was sure-fire. Alas. More on this a bit further on.
Quote:
Ten years ago I had my PS box rebuilt in the Dart by Steer and Gear in Ohio, it was $450 with fright one way,
And you had total confidence that it would work?
Quote:
$700 for something that goes right back in is reasonable.
Agreed, but only if there is total confidence that THAT would be the case, something which Ralph's response quoted in the Post to which you responded didn't seem to engender. BTW, when Lorrie was purchased in 1975, she cost $750.00 total!
Also, the $695.00 price made no mention about return shipping costs.
On the Straight Line Steering, Inc. webpage, there is the following paragraph found under
Freight Policy:
Quote:
All Units are sold F.O.B. Straight Line Steering, and cores are to be returned freight prepaid. Your order will be shipped as per your instructions. UPS, Federal Express, common carrier, or commercial airline.
Googled the term F.O.B. and got THIS:
Quote:
FOB stands for “free on board” or “freight on board” and is a designation is used to indicate when liability and ownership of goods is transferred from a seller to a buyer. When used with an identified physical location, the designation determines which party has responsibility for the payment of the freight charges and at what point title for the shipment passes from the seller to the buyer.
So "
F.O.B. Straight Line Steering" means that when the Unit is finished and is sitting at Straight Line Steering, it belongs to the owner of the Unit, and any shipping costs will be the owner's responsibility. So the $695.00 + (possibly tax) and shipping both ways would bring the cost up to approaching $800.00.
Quote:
Divide $700 by 55 years and that's 13 bucks a year before the next rebuild is due in 2073. LOL
It might be efficacious to include at this point a graphic that shows the kind of Steering Gear Box about which we are talking. The one shown is a LHD, but a RHD is the same KIND of mechanism: See HERE:
http://www.sweptline.org/steering63_68/19-01.gif
So what I'd like to do now is analyze what Ralph wrote, which will be once again quoted here:
Quote:
Hello, I can rebuild yours $695.00 I have rebuilt them in the past.
the rebuild will included new worm gear,roller.race cups,thrust bearings,sector seal,
3 day lead time once we received core, Thank you, Ralph
Due to strange punctuation, am unclear what the term "
new worm gear,roller." means. Is Ralph saying that the rebuild includes:
1. A "NEW Worm Gear"? Or is it a "NEW Worm Gear Roller."? And if it is the latter, what is a NEW Worm Gear Roller? Is THAT the Bearing Type?
2. Next, the term "
Roller.Race Cups" are in the Illustration, shown as being "Cage & Roller", with the drawing indicating that those are the Bearings, and the Cups are the parts that hold the Cage & Roller Bearings in place.
3. Alas, the exploded view referenced above has no listing for "Thrust Bearings". Am going to assume what Ralph intended that to mean is the "Sector Shaft Bushings".
So here is what I have concluded that Ralph at Straight Line Steering is proposing to do for $695.00 + tax and shipping: Install Two NEW Bearing Assemblies (Cages, Rollers, and Cups), Two NEW Sector Shaft Bushings, and a NEW Oil Seal. Then, of course, the Unit must be properly adjusted per the instructions in the 1967 Dodge Factory Shop Manual, of which there is a copy here.
Would you agree with the foregoing?
The looming question is: Will NEW Bearing Assemblies, NEW Sector Shaft Bushings, and a NEW Sector Shaft Oil Seal take the SLOP out of Lorrie's Steering?
We now come to the "What Ifs". What if the Worm Gear is worn out? What if the Gears on the Sector Shaft are worn out? Those two parts are what caused the OTHER rebuilders of Steering Gear Boxes to defer on the project.
And seeing as to how the Worm Gear and Sector Shaft are probably made of "Unobtainium", taking Lorrie's Gemmer Y4D-335 out and shipping it to San Jose California is looking less and less like something I'm willing to do.
Were I able to find the "Cage&Rollers", and the appropriate "Cups", and an "Oil Seal", I am almost certain that I could install them properly.
So the situation is this: Am going to have to think this over.
Straight Line Steering, Inc. is by all the reviews that have been found an honorable, and competent organization. BUT, even so, they cannot guarantee that Lorrie's Gemmer Y4D-335 RHD Manual Steering Gear Box will be rebuildable. But that's NOT their fault.
A final thought... If all that is going to be done is install two Bearing assembly, two Bushing, and an Oil Seal, without any assurance that it will solve the problem, $695.00 + tax and shipping DOES seem to be excessive. Nuff said.
Anyway, Mr. W. Thanks for the response and your positive attitude is commendable!
Hope this finds YOU doing well.
Take care.
JC